Hermiston Herald
April 2, 2002

Neutralization draws skepticism

By Frank Lockwood
Staff writer

HERMISTON - The Army can speed up the destruction of chemical agent and
perhaps save money by using neutralization on the mustard agent at the
Umatilla Chemical Depot, an assistant secretary of the Army says.
However, he said, "If the community doesn't want to do it, that's fine."
Mario Fiori, assistant secretary of the Army for Installations and
Environment, spoke at the PMCD Outreach Office last Tuesday about
accelerating chemical weapons destruction. "I'd like decrease the time that
it would take to get rid of (the nerve agent) by about four to five years,"
he said.

To speed incineration, the Army could go to three shifts, and employ
"reconfiguration," and change procedures at the incinerator in order to
process weapons faster.

"I find this a little confusing," said Morrow County Judge Terry Tallman,
"when we have been told that incineration is state of the art and the best
way to take care of this."

"I'm a believer in incineration," Fiori responded. "Neutralization is fairly
straight forward."

Hermiston community leaders, encouraged by the Army, have repeatedly spoken
for incineration but against neutralization for this site. Fiori anticipated
reluctance to accept the changes. "I have read ... 'We are on this path,
let's stay on it, don't deviate.' Well, we can do that if that's really what
the community wants. It won't get rid of that (agent) five years earlier
though."

Umatilla County Commissioner Dennis Doherty questioned the turn around.
"Speedy neutralization wasn't recommended six years ago, particularly by the
Army," Doherty said, and "What has changed that makes it of interest now?"
The Sept. 11 terrorist attacks added motivation for speeding weapons
destruction, Fiori said, but, otherwise, "Nothing has changed. I am just
interested in speeding up the process." On the other hand, the Army could
save several years by modifying incineration procedures, employing alternate
technologies, including neutralization of mustard, and by addressing
unspecified "regulation issues."

Incineration opponents have been alert for any indication Fiori would seek a
"Consent Decree," which amounts to a waiver of past permit decisions. DEQ's
Wayne Thomas said Friday that the state is not considering a Consent Decree.
And neutralization would not delay or slow incineration, Fiori said. "I want
to accelerate the throughput of that very safe incinerator. I want to make
sure that we are operating the most efficiently that's possible. I want to
investigate all presumptions in the way we work. I challenge the contractor
to come up with a whole bunch of ways to accelerate, if he could, and I
think it could easily save five years." Fiori said.

Neutralization is touted as a safer, faster way to destroy 2,635 tons of
mustard stored in Umatilla, which makes up about 64 percent of all the
chemical agent stockpile at the depot.

Comfortable With Incineration
"It has taken 11 or 12 years to get our people who are here somewhat
comfortable with the incineration process," said Umatilla Mayor George Hash.
"Now you want us to tell them differently." Hash and others questioned
adding alternative technologies to the budget when cash is short for present
safety programs.

"Present radio system can't keep contact with uptown and downtown Umatilla,"
Hash said.

"If we throw in anything new that (citizens) even perceive as delaying the
startup, we are going to have some unhappy people here," Hash said. "Don't
do anything that's going to delay the startup of this incineration process."
Fiori, however, said his goal was to speed up incineration, not to slow it
down.

Impacts Questioned
Morrow County Judge Terry Tallman suggested that running two plants at once
would aggravate a boom-bust cost to his community. He inquired as to whether
adding another facility - and the impacts on the communities it would bring
- would make federal impact aid any more likely.

"That's a valid issue, but I don't think you will get impact aid," Fiori
said.

Tallman had concerns about the environmental impact, and about waste
management.

"The depot is in a critical groundwater area," he said, "and what we have
been told about this technology is that it demands tremendous amounts of
water. One of the things we do not want to see is people's private wells and
the city's' wells be impacted because of this greater demand for water."
A release from Chemical Weapons Working group, however, challenged that
notion, saying that neutralization might use less water than incineration.
Tallman asked about the disposal of contaminated water which would be
generated by neutralization. "We don't have the facilities in Oregon to
handle it - the infrastructure," he said.

"The waste that comes from neutralization is fairly benign," Fiori noted.

"You will drown in it before you are poisoned by it." But Tallman responded
that he was concerned about the "sheer volume," not the toxicity of the
neutralization waste.

Other Interests
Increasing incinerator operations to three shifts, seven days per week,
would increase the need for on-duty CSEPP personnel, but money is not
budgeted for that, county commissioners said. Army spokesmen replied that
they needed round-the-clock response capabilities anyway, and that moving
munitions would only occur during daylight hours, under specific weather
conditions.

Morrow County Commissioner John Wenholz suggested that funding for safety
should be tied to any changes that would impact emergency preparedness.
"You say ... for the safety of the Unites States it is important that we
move this program ahead," Wenholz said. "I am saying, that for the safety of
the citizens that live in this area, we need whatever funding it takes to
provide for their safety."

"If you need more resources, I can't imagine not doing it," Fiori told those
present.

Goals the Same
Citizens Advisory Commission Chairman Bob Flournoy voiced a recurring theme
when he said, "If we do bring in new technology, we are not going to (want
to) slow anything down. Because that's what everyone's interested in.
Getting rid of this stuff.

"Yes sir," Fiori said. "We certainly agree with the goals that you just
said. And (incineration and neutralization) would be simultaneous
operations, if it ever happens. I am not slowing down incineration."

Frank Lockwood may be reached at 567-6457 or by e-mail at
flockwood@hermistonherald.com.