Army dumping sites targeted
By Jan TenBruggencate
Advertiser Science Writer
U.S. Sen. Daniel Akaka and Rep. Neil Abercrombie have introduced
legislation to require the Army to conduct complete studies and recommend
remediation of chemical weapon dumping sites off the Hawaiian Islands. U.S. Rep. Ed Case said he will co-sponsor the legislation. "Given the hazardous risks that these munitions may pose, it is important
for Congress to send the right message ... and ensure that the Army completes
its survey, monitors the sites and provides a plan for remediation," said
a written statement from Akaka. The Army decades ago dumped more than 8,000 tons of chemical munitions,
which contained blister agents and nerve agents, in at least three places
off south O'ahu and Wai'anae, but the exact locations and depth of the weaponry
are not clearly known. The Hawai'i lawmakers said they are concerned about
leakage from the toxic weapons that are known to have been dumped in 1944
and 1945 and other disposal programs that may have started as early as 1941
and continued to as late as 1972. The legislation calls for a complete report by September 2009 to
include the location and size of dump sites, the kinds of material present,
sampling and monitoring of the sites, and recommendations on how to deal
with them and how much that will cost. Hawai'i environmental groups said they support the legislation, but
would like to see it extended to include other kinds of munitions at other
Hawai'i sites on both the land and in the sea. "I would expand it to look at all the areas where munitions have
been dumped off Hawai'i," said Henry Curtis, executive director of Life of
the Land. "For example, when the military cleaned up Kaho'olawe, they never
looked at munitions in the water. I would hope for a comprehensive report
on both chemical and nonchemical weapons." Marjorie Ziegler, director of the Conservation Council for Hawai'i,
said there also are concerns about unexploded munitions at present and former
training ranges on land. "Munitions are of great concern. They are a deadly
form of land contamination that precludes future use. Let's not forget Makua,
Schofield Barracks, Waikane, Kane'ohe and Pohakuloa," Ziegler said. Case said the Army already has done considerable research on the
ocean-dumped chemical munitions, but he said the records apparently are not
complete. "It's crucial that we basically do three things here: identify, isolate
and clean up," he said. The legislation will "build a larger statutory framework
for what the department is already doing and it will formalize what the department
has already undertaken to do," he said. Abercrombie said he is pleased with the military's progress, but
wants a legislative role so that if additional money is needed for the process,
it can be handled quickly. "Our goal is to get the facts and then move to a well-thought-out
plan of action. The Department of Defense will have to be deeply involved
in gathering this information, and that's why we're using the annual national
defense authorization bill as the legislative vehicle," Abercrombie said.
If more resources are needed, "we will already have it there and we will
not have to invent it on the spot." Reach Jan TenBruggencate at jant@honoluluadvertiser.com